Joan’s second nerf came with the talent tree 2.0 update. But alternatively, if they are 5/1/1/1 or a bit higher, then epics will rate higher than they do here.For a better depiction, check out the original scores in the commander tier list calculator. Once considered on par with some of the legendary commanders, she has fallen from grace to just another balanced epic.She has taken two main hits:The first is the nerf of her fourth skill. Level Joan of Arc to 2 ⭐ and max out her second skill. At the same time, Joan of Arc will be able to clamp down on the enemy’s movement, making it easier for her army to finish them off. Download Rise of Kingdoms on PC for free! There are two main reasons for this:The insane cost of maxing commanders.The underlying combat formulas involve so many variables, and many skill descriptions are unclear as to how they fit into it.In other games where you can experience more commanders firsthand, there can be some real value in anecdotal experiences. From running a majorette school, book store, writer and painter. Gathering Speed Bonus: 5% / 10% / 15% / 20% / 25%Troop Load Bonus: 5% / 10% / 15% / 20% / 25%. So sprinkle my words with that same scepticism (but maybe I get some extra points for reliability if you’re feeling generous).I hope you have gotten some value out of this guide. Another Rise of Kingdoms commander guide. I know you did further down, so perhaps make a hotlink to that section from one of the categories/things I have already mentioned aswell as shown you in my incredibly awesome (self-made!!) Talent … An easy way to get around this is pairing her with another gatherer such as Centurion. If you are using Joan, unlocking her expertise is a high priority. How the scores were calculatedThese scores are based on the total power scores in the commander tier list calculator (which has its own limitations). Poor old Joan has had a rough time of it lately. So I underestimate her a little. Joan and Jake lived in Pittsford and were married for 52 years. For this reason alone, she is worth investing in.A common misconception is that she should only be used with the gathering talent tree. C Effect can only trigger once every 5 seconds.Upgrade Preview: Healing Factor: 150 / 200 / 250 / 350 / 450CommentsWorks as described. However, in reality, a nuking composition would be much better served by another nuker, or someone who is going to give it more staying power.Due to this nerf, Joan is no longer prime material for main combat pairs (that is not to understate her importance on the battlefield though). Joan does both of these beautifully. I kind of quit since the alliance I joined… kind of died, and I got blamed for being a “spy” recruiting for our main rivals… Just because I tried to glue us back together, organized a Discord server for all the allies + alliance itself…. For this reason alone, she is worth investing in.A common misconception is that she should only be used with the gathering talent tree. While some of you might prefer her to play the role as the gathering commander. Alternatively, you can take her to 4 stars for right after maxing her 2nd skill if you want to start using her for combat. In an isolated situation, there is always a better alternative she could be replaced with. And um.. An easy way to get around this is pairing her with another gatherer such as Centurion. Welcome to the Commander Talent Tree Planner for Rise of Civilizations. You might turn up to a battlefield swarming with Joans. So sprinkle my words with that same scepticism (but maybe I get some extra points for reliability if you’re feeling generous). In which case you might’ve been better off bringing a different support.Semi-Support I pretty much put any non-support pairing of Joan in this category. Yeah sorry about the conflicting information. I am planning on starting up a discord for like minded players though. For example, I think you should start with the recommended roles at the top (aswell as for your future guides) Since alot of new players [like me] may come here to try and find role & for their current primary Commander or maybe even their ‘first choice’, in which case mentioning the primary uses for her right off the bat might be a good idea. Previously it didn’t matter which commander was in the primary position as far as talents were concerned. However, this is not true. Whenever your troops is at low health, there’s a chance both will heal that adds slight edge to survivability. To stop them from unjustly overshadowing epics more than they should, the legendary commanders are an average of: Score given = (2 x maxed legendary score + 1 x 5/1/1/1 legendary score) / 3. To do this, from scores 0 to 9 are linear, and then the outliers are compressed into 9 to 10 on their own linear scale.Then there was also the question of how to compare legendaries to the other commanders as they are much harder to max. In 1456, an inquisitorial court examined the trial, debunked the charges against her, pronounced her innocent, and declared her a martyr.eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'houseofkingdoms_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_6',136,'0','0'])); In the 16th century she became a symbol of the Catholic League, and in 1803 she was declared a national symbol of France by the decision of Napoleon Bonaparte.eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'houseofkingdoms_com-box-4','ezslot_5',137,'0','0'])); Download Rise of Kingdoms on PC for free! Joan does both of these beautifully. So until I do, Legend Rhony has been kind enough to give me permission to use his diagrams.Legend Rhony’s Gathering BuildLegend Rhony’s Support BuildSContrary to this build, I think there would be more value in completing the support tree before branching off into the integration tree. How the scores were calculatedThese scores are based on the total power scores in the commander tier list calculator (which has its own limitations). Joan does both of these beautifully. Alright so…except that; I reckon hotlinks to your different sections in the guide would be awesome aswell (Gives people an overview of what is included in the guide too; it’s not mainly for the ‘convenience’ /laziness so to speak. Seeing as it is an AOE buff, you can get most of Joan’s value just by having her near. Descent of the Goddess is an enhanced skill that improves existing active skill by increasing the duration of buff to 4 seconds and generating 50 rage per second. It will help you survive longer so you can squeeze in as many buffs/debuffs as possible.Joan on Wheels BuildIf you’re looking to put your Joan skills to the test, check out this guide.Beware of Commander AdviceWhen it comes to commander comparisons, approach any advice with a healthy dose of scepticism.This game is particularly hard to gauge commanders. She will work well as a secondary to most legendary and epic commanders. However, the most effective semi support compositions will always be the more damage focused variations of the support pairings.Talent Tree BuildsI have yet to look into talent trees in any real depth. I spent a lot of time combing through each commander while creating my commander tier list calculator. You will want the primary in your support combo to have either a support talent path or a skill path. You will want the primary in your support combo to have either a support talent path or a skill path. Especially seeing as she is one of the few commanders with the support talent tree. It also affects counterattacks. Contrary to this build, I think there would be more value in completing the support tree before branching off into the integration tree. I spent a lot of time combing through each commander while creating my commander tier list calculator. She has a nice little heal which keeps her on the battlefield for longer. Pelagius is a good secondary commander to pair with Joan of Arc for a number of reasons. A support has two main focuses: to use their support skills as often as possible for the benefit of nearby friendly armies, and to increase survivability. BlueStacks is the emulator of choice for over 500,000 RoK players.Analysis Note: While writing this analysis, I was still under the impression that Joan’s normal attack damage bonus only affected the troop attacks and not the counterattacks. Here, she took a real hit to her versatility. Previously Joan was a great addition to any pairing to beef it out a bit more. CommentsJoan has one of the strongest expertise. My analysis will never be perfect, so please leave your thoughts in the comments section below. But it is not all linear.To keep the scores comparable, I’ve had to prevent the highest scoring commanders in some tier lists from distorting it. As I said earlier, in my books, if Joan isn’t in a support composition, it is, by default, a semi support composition. Insane Aethelflaed Talent Tree Build and Guide Table of Contents show Aethelflaed is by far the most useful commander in every aspect of Rise of Kingdoms. By doing so, you can piggyback off his gathering tree, while still getting the full benefit of Joan’s gathering skill. Joan of arc excels at being sub-commander to siege commanders due to her high defence, rage bonus and aoe heal for all groups. In saying that, I hold by the analysis, the only difference is that she performs better as a semi-support than I originally anticipated.Poor old Joan has had a rough time of it lately. So you certainly want Joan around, just not in your main fighting pair if you can avoid it.A lot of love still lingers around for Joan from her glory days. So it’s always thoroughly appreciated. So until I do, Legend Rhony has been kind enough to give me permission to use his diagrams.Legend Rhony’s Gathering BuildLegend Rhony’s Support BuildSContrary to this build, I think there would be more value in completing the support tree before branching off into the integration tree. In the next 2 seconds, Joan of Arc grants her own troops and nearby friendly forces a powerful buff that increases infantry units’ health by 30%, increases cavalry units’ defense by 30%, increases archer units’ attack by 30%, and grants an additional 40 rage per second. If she is being run as a secondary, the easiest way to spot a Joan is to look for the animation of her active skill. Had to format my phone and currently playing through the intro so I can logon my account instead. As I said earlier, in my books, if Joan isn’t in a support composition, it is, by default, a semi support composition. This is the birthplace of much misinformation.This is not to say there aren’t smart people with great advice out there. This presents a perfect opportunity to take advantage of Joan of Arc’s active skill for a blanket buff to all troops. © 2020-2021 House of Kingdoms | All Rights Reserved. The last thing I have to say is…well…the skills at the top/start of the guide… I kind of wish I could see them side by side but I pondered a bit over how that could be fixed and didn’t really come up with a solution. Joan’s second nerf came with the talent tree 2.0 update. ... William Skills, Talent Tree and Pairings; This is where her main value lies. But whether it is the better option than running a pure support march will be super situational.The three main factors to consider are:Which commanders with support skills will already be on the battlefield.The relative strength of your troops (tier and research) compared to your allies and the enemy.Your own commanders and troop numbers, and the pros and cons of other possible combinations you could run instead.Example: If you were a strong player, fighting alone with 3 full marches, it might make more sense to run Joan as a semi-support. But when you can only maintain a few commanders, all you have to go off are how they interact with other armies of various strength, along with watching other people’s armies in the same way. Passive Skill Increases normal attack damage byx%. Your much stronger than average troops will be able to contribute more than if you ran them under a support tree.On the BattlefieldBy now you should have an appreciation for how helpful Joan is to bring along to a battle. How the scores were calculatedThese scores are based on the total power scores in the commander tier list calculator (which has its own limitations). This is done through either the commander pairing or the talent tree chosen. It has either compromised its fighting ability to bring a debuff/disable/AOE buff into the fight, or it is sacrificing its support potential to bring a bit more damage to the table. On 23 May 1430, she was captured at Compiègne and later put on trial.eval(ez_write_tag([[580,400],'houseofkingdoms_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_3',135,'0','0'])); After the Bishop Pierre Cauchon declared her guilty she was burned at the stake on 30 May 1431, dying at about nineteen years of age. Seeing as it is an AOE buff, you can get most of Joan’s value just by having her near. House of Kingdoms is the biggest Rise of Kingdoms guides and tips. (nee Wasmer) age 99, passed away December 26, 2020. To stop them from unjustly overshadowing epics more than they should, the legendary commanders are an average of:Score given = (2 x maxed legendary score + 1 x 5/1/1/1 legendary score) / 3So if you have maxed legendaries, they will rank higher in relation to the scores given here for epics. It starts with a large circle which shows the range of the AOE:And then has small circles rippling out from the march while it is under the effect of the buff:Alternatively, if you want to zoom in, you can also look out for the blue lady on a horse:If you see a Joan, it’s usually best to target her right away. I was thinking Frederick, who I started to level up for that very reason so he's like around 20-30 (not 30, but somewhere in between since I need to max certain skills which will take some time seeing how they use the same sculptures for both stars and skills if I'm not mistaken), Anyhow; atm my setup is as follows: Offense: Ceasar + Frederick Secondary offensive-ish setup consists of Boudica and well, depends on the situation but I usually pick Joan/Sun Tsu (/one of the three barbarian-related killing machines; Lohar/Minamoto/…err, I think Boudica was the 'third' one I was thinking off because of one of her skills), Anyways. She has a nice little heal which keeps her on the battlefield for longer. To do this, from scores 0 to 9 are linear, and then the outliers are compressed into 9 to 10 on their own linear scale.Then there was also the question of how to compare legendaries to the other commanders as they are much harder to max. It is an AOE buff which affects allies in a small circle around Joan. However, rather than scoring them with just their skills, their total scores are ranked relative to one another. However, the most effective semi support compositions will always be the more damage focused variations of the support pairings.Talent Tree BuildsI have yet to look into talent trees in any real depth. This buff can be applied for every garrison when this leader is serving as a garrison commander. It is a perfectly legitimate use of Joan. And finally, her infantry health and cavalry defence buffs give her more staying power. Ideally, you want Joan for her support tree as the primary commander. For this reason alone, she is worth investing in.A common misconception is that she should only be used with the gathering talent tree. Simply by virtue of where Joan’s value lies.She will work well as a secondary to most legendary and epic commanders. If you are planning on running her in the primary position, keep going! Joan’s second nerf came with the talent tree 2.0 update. This series aims to help you pick the best commanders for your situation and how to get the most out of them. Everyone should max her skills eventually. Joan’s second nerf came with the talent tree 2.0 update. The family wishes to thank Joan's wonderful caregivers whose dedicated service preserved her comfort during her final years. You just have to acknowledge it for what it is. If she is being run as a secondary, the easiest way to spot a Joan is to look for the animation of her active skill. Seeing as it is an AOE buff, you can get most of Joan’s value just by having her near. For this reason alone, she is worth investing in.A common misconception is that she should only be used with the gathering talent tree. It more than doubles the effectiveness of her first skill, Divine Revelation. However, the most effective semi support compositions will always be the more damage focused variations of the support pairings.Talent Tree BuildsI have yet to look into talent trees in any real depth. There are two main reasons for this:The insane cost of maxing commanders.The underlying combat formulas involve so many variables, and many skill descriptions are unclear as to how they fit into it.In other games where you can experience more commanders firsthand, there can be some real value in anecdotal experiences. Previously Joan was a great addition to any pairing to beef it out a bit more. If you don’t have Julius Caesar in your roster, Scipio Africanus is a solid alternative choice. In the next part of our Best Joan of Arc commander guide, I am going to talk about star level & talent point upgrade priority to maximize your commander’s combat potential. I am really clueless as to what commanders to focus on right now except Frederick and Joan. Sad face.While she is no longer a strong option for a main combat pairing, her active skill’s buff is as important as ever. Especially seeing as she is one of the few commanders with the support talent tree.A support has two main focuses: to use their support skills as often as possible for the benefit of nearby friendly armies, and to increase survivability. Joan shines in the support role. If she is being run as a secondary, the easiest way to spot a Joan is to look for the animation of her active skill. For this reason alone, she is worth investing in.A common misconception is that she should only be used with the gathering talent tree. You might turn up to a battlefield swarming with Joans. She comes with a base power of 600 and skills in Integration, Gathering and Support. Joan is only valuable when multiple marches are able to benefit from her AOE buff. In an isolated situation, there is always a better alternative she could be replaced with. Especially seeing as she is one of the few commanders with the support talent tree.A support has two main focuses: to use their support skills as often as possible for the benefit of nearby friendly armies, and to increase survivability. A lot of love still lingers around for Joan from her glory days. Alternatively, you can roll Belisarius if you don’t have Pelagius. Games like these lose a bunch of the appeal when the social side to it goes. Joan does both of these beautifully. Secondly, regarding your talent builds; maybe include a summary of what the talents for each of the builds actually provide? Works the best with gathering talent build and when rolling pure siege army.eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'houseofkingdoms_com-large-leaderboard-2','ezslot_9',150,'0','0'])); Troops’ normal attack has a 10% chance to heal some of the slightly wounded units. Mail me at either robin@arotikah.se or ginnungagap.j@gmail.com if you’re interested. Robin 'nihil' Jiglund January 30, 2019, 2:39 am. They are only intended as a rough guideline. With enough discussion, it will be a valuable resource in and of itself.Take the commander scores below lightly. There’s a reason Joan is the best support. Here, they are placed on a 0 to 10 scale.In this scale, 0 is 0, and 10 is the highest ranking commander’s contribution score in a given tier list. A small chance that your troops will get heal on a normal attack. Your much stronger than average troops will be able to contribute more than if you ran them under a support tree.On the BattlefieldBy now you should have an appreciation for how helpful Joan is to bring along to a battle. CommentsJoan has one of the strongest expertise. Previously it didn’t matter which commander was in the primary position as far as talents were concerned. While it is a decent skill by its own right, it is not as strong as damage reduction. But now, the only time Joan can legitimately be run as a primary is in a support setup (and a gatherer of course). Seeing as it is an AOE buff, you can get most of Joan’s value just by having her near. The duration of this active skill lats for 2 seconds. Can I make linebreaks etc here? No worries! Talent Builds Joan of Arc: B+: B-B-A+: C: S-Joan of Arc is actually a really nice commander when fully rocking her support tree and she will boost the whole army and when you pair her up with a commander that can benefit from that, she will rock the party.???? I am a bit confused… In your quizz to choose your commanders, the pair scipion/Jeanne is proposed quite often as a good option for ftp and low buyer… but in this article, you are saying that this pairing is no more worth pursuing…. However, this is not true. This is where her main value lies. She has the best rage regeneration skill in the game, and paired with a support tree, she pops off actives like it’s nobody’s business. Active Skill Rage Requirement: 1000 In the next 2 seconds, Joan of Arc grants her own troops and nearby friendly forces a powerful buff that increases infantry units’ health by x%, increases cavalry units’ defense by x%, increases archer units’ attack by x%, and grants an additional x rage per second. I especially like the hotlinks suggestion. Talen tree của Joan of Arc. But now, the only time Joan can legitimately be run as a primary is in a support setup (and a gatherer of course). If she is being run as a secondary, the easiest way to spot a Joan is to look for the animation of her active skill. Everyone should max her skills eventually. I spent a lot of time combing through each commander while creating my commander tier list calculator. I mean, what language is used here if so? The commander quiz in its current state only gives the possible pairings rather than recommending what’s best. So until I do, Legend Rhony has been kind enough to give me permission to use his diagrams.Legend Rhony’s Gathering BuildLegend Rhony’s Support BuildSContrary to this build, I think there would be more value in completing the support tree before branching off into the integration tree. To stop them from unjustly overshadowing epics more than they should, the legendary commanders are an average of:Score given = (2 x maxed legendary score + 1 x 5/1/1/1 legendary score) / 3So if you have maxed legendaries, they will rank higher in relation to the scores given here for epics. It starts with a large circle which shows the range of the AOE: And then has small circles rippling out from the march while it is under the effect of the buff: Alternatively, if you want to zoom in, you can also look out for the blue lady on a horse: If you see a Joan, it’s usually best to target her right away. To do this, from scores 0 to 9 are linear, and then the outliers are compressed into 9 to 10 on their own linear scale. She has the best rage regeneration skill in the game, and paired with a support tree, she pops off actives like it’s nobody’s business. How the scores were calculatedThese scores are based on the total power scores in the commander tier list calculator (which has its own limitations). It is important to point out that her passive skills is actually really good and makes her viable for PvP battles and support role. Nor does it fit with Joan’s skill set. It doesn’t take too much of a jump in reasoning to recognise the importance of removing your enemy’s Joan from the battle ASAP.If the enemy is running her as a primary, you won’t have any troubles finding her portrait. Joan Of Arc is the best support and farming commander in the Rise Of Kingdoms. However, in reality, a nuking composition would be much better served by another nuker, or someone who is going to give it more staying power.Due to this nerf, Joan is no longer prime material for main combat pairs (that is not to understate her importance on the battlefield though). Oh what the hell. Just that much of what you will hear will be nothing more than speculation.How I would rank the reliability of comparisons (approach with your newfound scepticism):Testing done under properly controlled conditionsTheorycrafting with some serious maths.Testing is done against barbarians or other players not at identical research levels etc.Anecdotal experience.Hearsay.Guesswork.I’ve tried to base a lot of what I do off number 2 in that list. It has either compromised its fighting ability to bring a debuff/disable/AOE buff into the fight, or it is sacrificing its support potential to bring a bit more damage to the table. Nor does it fit with Joan’s skill set. So I underestimate her a little. While it is a decent skill by its own right, it is not as strong as damage reduction. Just that much of what you will hear will be nothing more than speculation.How I would rank the reliability of comparisons (approach with your newfound scepticism):Testing done under properly controlled conditionsTheorycrafting with some serious maths.Testing is done against barbarians or other players not at identical research levels etc.Anecdotal experience.Hearsay.Guesswork.I’ve tried to base a lot of what I do off number 2 in that list. So, let’s find out the best talent builds to use for this epic commander. If the enemy is running her as a primary, you won’t have any troubles finding her portrait. This build basically takes all the resource gathering talents in the Gathering Tree and then picks up all the extra march speed talents in the Support Tree and the Integration Tree that you can get afterward.. Just try to steer clear of the advice to pair her with your main commander if you are planning on dealing out damage or tanking efficiently. The commanders who run well as support (in no particular order) are: Richard, Hannibal, El Cid, Cao Cao, Belisarius, Hermann, Eulji, Pelagius, Boudica and Cleopatra.Ideally, you want Joan for her support tree as the primary commander.Semi-SupportA semi support is a cross between a fighting pair and a supporting pair. ... Joan of Arc. Keep at level 18-20 (if you want to use her for combat too, you might want to stay there until her first skill is also maxed).Then take her to 3 stars and leave her at level 27 for the gathering talent tree.When you are ready to take her to level 37 for the final part of the gathering tree, 4 star her.Alternatively, you can take her to 4 stars for right after maxing her 2nd skill if you want to start using her for combat.CombatKeep at 1 star until the first skill is maxed.Then level her to four stars before continuing to max her skills.If you are only planning to use her as a secondary, you can keep her at level 30 (or 37 to max out the gathering speed talents).If you are planning on running her in the primary position, keep going!Have you ever wanted to play Rise of Kingdoms on your computer?